Dual View All Problems Random Open
OPEN
Which polarizable $\mathbb{Q}$-Hodge structures of weight $2$ with Hodge numbers $$h^{2,0}=n, h^{1,1}=0, h^{0,2}=n,$$ with $n\geq 2$, are motivic?
The open status of this problem reflects the current belief of the owner of this website. There may be literature on this problem that I am unaware of, which may partially or completely solve the stated problem. Please do your own literature search before expending significant effort on solving this problem. If you find any relevant literature not mentioned here, please add this in a comment.
Comment activity that has not yet been incorporated into the remarks
There are no solutions, partial or complete, claimed in the comments.
General remarks

The main difficulty in this question is that, while Hodge structures with the given Hodge numbers are parametrized by a positive-dimensional period domain, it follows from Griffiths transversality that only countably many can be motivic. This question is considered in e.g. [T15], but it seems that little is known. An answer for $n=2$ would already be interesting.

For $n=1$, all such Hodge structures are CM (and hence arise in middle cohomology of the square of a CM elliptic curve).

Formalizability

The statement is probably hard to formalize as of May 2026.

Some speculation on the problem's difficulty

This problem is plausibly quite difficult; as far as I know there is not yet a good conjectural answer.

Comments on interest

This case is perhaps the simplest in which Griffiths transversality places strong constraints on period images; our lack of knowledge about it shows how little we know about such. A characterization of motivic Hodge structures of the type above would likely be quite interesting.

View the LaTeX source

This page was last edited 16 May 2026. View history

Likes this problem Antoni-K_Piotr, qln4roe64
Interested in collaborating None
Currently working on this problem Antoni-K_Piotr
This problem looks difficult None
This problem looks tractable None
The results on this problem could be formalisable None
I am working on formalising the results on this problem None

If you wish to acknowledge this website, the recommended citation format is:

D. Litt, Problem #11, https://www.problemsilike.com/11, accessed 2026-11-15
Order by oldest first or newest first. (The most recent comments are highlighted in a red border.)
  • I think they will not all be CM though, at least for $n = 2$.

    I can compute an explicit non-CM weight $(1,3)$ Hilbert modular form $f$ over $F = \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{5})$. If I consider the $\ell$-adic Galois representation $\rho_f \colon G_F \rightarrow \mathrm{GL}_2(\overline{\mathbb{Q}_\ell})$ for some prime $\ell$ split in $F$, say with $v, v' | \ell$, then the Hodge-Tate weights of $G_{F_v}$ and $G_{F_{v'}}$ are (WLOG) $(1,1)$ and $(0, 2)$.

    The tensor induction $\mathrm{TInd}_{G_{\mathbb{F}}}^{G_{\mathbb{Q}}} \rho_f$ will then be a $4$-dimensional strongly irreducible geometric $G_{\mathbb{Q}}$-representation with Hodge-Tate weights $(1,1,3,3)$. Twisting the tensor induction by the inverse cyclotomic character, I can get a $4$-dimensional geometric $G_{\mathbb{Q}}$-representation $\xi$ with Hodge-Tate weights $(0,0,2,2)$.

    For the specific form $f$ that I started with, the coefficients satisfy some nice symmetries, and the Frobenius traces of $\xi$ appear to all be valued in $\mathbb{Q}$.

    Conjecturally, I think this $\xi$ should be the $\ell$-adic realization of some motive $M$ over $\mathbb{Q}$ with coefficients in $\mathbb{Q}$ and Hodge vector $(2,0,2)$. This motive $M$ shouldn't be CM since $f$ wasn't CM - I think $M$ should have Mumford-Tate Lie algebra $\mathfrak{sl_2}^{\oplus 2}$ from the construction.

  • There are other examples in the literature, but here's one surface with maximal Picard rank and $h^{2,0} = 2$ (so giving an example for $n = 2$). It's the desingularization of the double cover of $\mathbb{P}^2$ given by the affine equation $t^2 = xy(x^2-1)(y^2-1)(x^2-y^2)$. This surface has a several automorphisms and the resulting motive appears to be CM, so it's not super exciting though.

    This example is a specialization of a family found by van Geemen and Top. Below is the only part of the argument that's different from what they do (they're interested in constructing a $(2,4,2)$ motive with certain properties, so the numerology they want is different).

    The branch locus is a union of 8 lines. Drawing it out, it has 4 double points, 6 triple points, and one fourfold singularity. What are the cycles on the desingularization of the double cover?

    - Each double point contributes a single exceptional $\mathbb{P}^1$ (4 x 1 = 4).
    - Each triple point contributes four exceptional $\mathbb{P}^1$s. (6 x 4 = 24)
    - The fibre above the fourfold singularity is an elliptic curve (it looks like a double cover of a $\mathbb{P}^1$ branched at four points) (1 x 1 = 1)
    - The preimage of the hyperplane section on $\mathbb{P}^2$ (1)

    In total, this gives us $\dim \mathrm{NS}(X) = 30$. The arguments in [Section 3, vGT94] imply that $h^{2,0} = 2$ and that $h^2(X) = 34$.

    I haven't written this part down, but I think *any* union of 8 lines with the requisite intersection properties is determined by a choice of any four points in $\mathbb{P}^2$, and as a result (since the automorphisms of $\mathbb{P^2}$ act 4-transitively) the resulting surface is isomorphic to this one. Another way to think about this is that if changing my choice of 4 points could give me something different than the CM example, then I think I'd be able to form families and violate Griffiths transversality!

    Anyways, if we want to try to get a non-CM example using this sort of construction, we'd need a more exotic degree-8 (see [vGT94]) branch locus.

    Bertin and Elencwajg also give a construction [Proposition 3.2, BE87] of an elliptic surface with maximal Picard rank, realized again via a branched double cover of the plane. Their construction is not with 8 lines but with two conics and four lines [Figure 2, BE87] ([vGT94] explain why such examples need to have $h^2(X) = 34$ and branch locus of degree $8$). I suspect this example is also CM, but I haven't checked it. As with the other construction though, there seems to be a lot of leeway in the choice of four of the points in Figure 2, so I wonder if all the choices give isomorphic elliptic surfaces.

  • Maybe it is worth adding some motivic examples with n > 1? If I understand correctly, one construction I have in mind relies on Theorem 15 of S. Schreieder, On the construction problem for Hodge numbers, Geom. Topol. {\bf 19} (2015), no.~1, 295--342 to construct a projective variety X with degree-2 Hodge numbers (n,1,n). Then after taking out an ample class, the primitive H^2 has Hodge numbers (n,0,n).

    • Yes, I should add some comments along these lines! In general (as you say) one possible construction is via surfaces with maximal Picard rank; many such are known.

All comments are the responsibility of the user. Comments appearing on this page are not verified for correctness. Please keep posts mathematical and on topic.

Log in to add a comment.

Back to the forum