Dual View All Problems Random Open
OPEN
Fix $G\in \mathbb{Q}(z, y_0, y_1, \cdots, y_{n-1}), N\in \mathbb{Z}_{>0}$ and suppose $f(z)\in \mathbb{Z}[\frac{1}{N}][[z]]$ satisfies $$f^{(n)}(z)=G(z, f(z), f'(z), \cdots, f^{(n-1)}(z)).$$ Suppose further that $G(0, f(0), \cdots, f^{(n-1)}(0))$ is defined. Is it necessarily the case that $f(z)$ is the Taylor expansion at $0$ of an algebraic function?
#1 Daniel Litt
The open status of this problem reflects the current belief of the owner of this website. There may be literature on this problem that I am unaware of, which may partially or completely solve the stated problem. Please do your own literature search before expending significant effort on solving this problem. If you find any relevant literature not mentioned here, please add this in a comment.
Comment activity that has not yet been incorporated into the remarks
There are no solutions, partial or complete, claimed in the comments.
General remarks

This is a version of Conjecture 1.1.1 of [LL25], though surely it has been considered earlier--perhaps as early as Eisenstein's final paper [E52], where he proved that Taylor expansions of algebraic functions lie in $\mathbb{Z}[\frac{1}{N}][[z]]$--that is, only finitely many primes appear in the denominators of their Taylor coefficients. For linear ODE, some version of this conjecture has been considered by Andr\'e and Christol, see e.g. Remarque 5.3.2 of [A04]. [LL25] proves a number of special cases for ODE (and initial conditions) with some algebro-geometric meaning.

Note that the condition that $G(0, f(0), \cdots, f^{(n-1)}(0))$ is defined is necessary; otherwise (for example) the power series $$f(z)=\sum_n {2n \choose n}^2\left(\frac{z}{16}\right)^n$$ is a counterexample. In other words, one needs to be taking the Taylor expansion at a non-singular point of our differential equation. The case of singular points (and linear ODE) is considered by Christol in e.g. [C84]; it would be interesting to find a reasonable conjecture in the non-linear case.

Formalizability

The statement has now been formalized, see here.

Some speculation on the problem's difficulty

My expectation is that substantial new ideas are needed to resolve this question, assuming the answer is, as I expect, "yes." One natural case to consider would be the case of Picard-Fuchs equations (or Gauss-Manin connections) where already the conjecture is open in general, though Theorem 3.1.1 of [LL25] resolves it in the case of initial conditions which are a linear combination of cycle classes, for example. I expect a number of other special cases of this sort to be doable with existing techniques.

If the answer is "no," it's quite possible that there is a simple counterexample (perhaps already implicit in the literature) -- in this case it would be good to try to repair the question appropriately.

Comments on interest

I think of this and related questions as being among the most basic open problems in the theory of algebraic differential equations. It is closely related to--though it seems neither to follow from nor imply--the Grothendieck-Katz $p$-curvature conjecture [K72] (for linear ODE) and the Ekedahl--Shepherd-Barron--Taylor conjecture [ESBT99] (for non-linear ODE). See [2] for a special case of the $p$-curvature conjecture.

View the LaTeX source

This page was last edited 29 May 2026. View history

Likes this problem fridirick, JoseBrox
Interested in collaborating JoseBrox
Currently working on this problem JoseBrox
This problem looks difficult JoseBrox
This problem looks tractable JoseBrox
The results on this problem could be formalisable None
I am working on formalising the results on this problem seewoo5

If you wish to acknowledge this website, the recommended citation format is:

D. Litt, Problem #1, https://www.problemsilike.com/1, accessed 2026-11-15
Order by oldest first or newest first. (The most recent comments are highlighted in a red border.)

All comments are the responsibility of the user. Comments appearing on this page are not verified for correctness. Please keep posts mathematical and on topic.

Log in to add a comment.

Back to the forum